Never Mind The Polls: Watch The Prediction Markets
(Cross posted at Daily Kos)
"Follow the money."
That's what Deep Throat told Woodward and Bernstein. For good or bad, I think it has almost always been true about politics.
That said, there are more than a few "prediction markets" that track buying and selling of contracts that predict outcomes in political races.
Intrade is one such prediction market. It is a trading exchange for politics, current events, financial Indicators, weather & other unique contracts.
Here's an example of how it works:
If you buy one "House Republican Majority" contract at today's bid price of 48 AND the GOP does retain control of the House in November, THEN that contract will close, or settle, at 100. Your profit will be 52 points x 10ยข per point or $5.20. If, on the other hand, the goopers lose control, well, you lose, too -- all the money you spent to buy the contracts at 48 each is down the drain.
So, when you bid and buy at 48, you are essentially putting your money where your mouth is. You are saying you believe there is a 48% chance that the House will remain under Republican control.
Similarly, when traders bid and buy at today's price of 80 on "Senate Republican Majority" contracts, they are telling us that they believe that the GOP has an 80% chance hanging on to the Senate.
Is this a perfect system for predicting outcomes? Not necessarily. But like I said -- follow the money. Traders enter the market to make money, which is as good a way as any to measure the accuracy of the information that they use to make their trading decisions.
That said, here's what the market is predicting in specific Senate contests -- remember, the percentage represents the chance of that candidate winning, not his or her approval rating or any other kind of polling response:
- Connecticut: Lieberman (60%, mkt is up) beats Lamont and Schlesinger
- Missouri: Talent (55%, mkt is steady) beats McCaskill
- Montana: Tester (60%, mkt is steady) beats Burns
- Ohio: Brown (66%, mkt is up) beats DeWine
- Pennsylvania: Casey (75%, mkt is steady) beats Santorum
- Rhode Island: Whitehouse (70%, mkt is steady) beats either Chafee or Laffey
- Tennessee: Corker (70%, mkt is steady) beats Ford
- Virginia: Allen (65%, mkt is down) beats Webb
Intrade is not the only one by any means. I would encourage y'all to scan other prediction markets. Bring your results here and let's discuss what we're seeing.

Comments
TradeSports is another. They are cool.
Yours,
Wince
Posted by: Wince and Nod
|
August 29, 2006 01:52 AM
Some have observed that prediction markets are accurate when the contract trading volumes are high. These contracts are trading at low volumes (so far)...who knows?
Posted by: Ara Rubyan
|
August 29, 2006 06:37 AM